There is no Thanksgiving dessert more iconic than pumpkin pie. 🥰 Any Thanksgiving dinner without this delicious pie just feels incomplete! In fact, most family Thanksgiving dinners include a few pumpkin pies so everyone can get their fill.
This pie is so popular not only because it’s scrumptious, but because it’s seasonal. While you can make pumpkin pie year round, it’s the freshest in the fall season. Besides, it just doesn’t feel right having pumpkin pie in the spring, does it?
Thanksgiving is drawing ever closer, which means that it’s time to find the perfect Thanksgiving pumpkin pie recipe!
If you’re new to baking your own pie, the amount of recipes online may seem overwhelming.
So, we have put together a list of the best Thanksgiving pumpkin pie recipes to suit a wide variety of dietary needs and baking abilities:
Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie with Canned Pumpkins
Are you a pumpkin pie lover, but a sub-par baker? Don’t worry! The best thing about Thanksgiving pumpkin pie recipes is that many used canned pumpkins.
Not only are these pumpkin pies faster to cook, but they’re unbelievably easy to make! And they taste just as good made with canned pumpkin puree.
Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie
This old fashioned pumpkin pie recipe is filled with all of the traditional spices. A mixture of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves, and cardamom give this pie its classic taste.
Quick and Easy Pumpkin Pie
This is the easiest pumpkin pie recipe of all! Simply mix all of the ingredients together, pour into a pie crust, and bake!
Pumpkin Pie Using Fresh Pumpkins
If you enjoy the art of baking, then these are the pumpkin pie recipes for you! These pies are made with fresh pumpkin. While they make take a bit longer to make, you can show off your baking expertise!
Nothing compares to Thanksgiving pumpkin pie made with fresh ingredients.
Fresh Pumpkin Pie
If you have ample time to spend in the kitchen, this fresh pumpkin pie recipe is well worth it. It uses all fresh ingredients for the most wholesome pumpkin pie.
Fresh Spiced Pumpkin Pie
With a flavor so rich, you’d be surprised that this pumpkin pie recipe has so few ingredients! All you need is some fresh cooked pumpkin and basic household ingredients.
Gluten & Dairy Free Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Choices
Everyone should be able to enjoy pumpkin pie on Thanksgiving, don’t you think? Unfortunately, many people with gluten or dairy allergies have to pass on the pie. But not this year!
These gluten and dairy free pumpkin pie recipes are both delicious and perfect for family with food intolerances.
Gluten and Dairy-Free Pumpkin Pie
This pumpkin pie gets its flavor from almond milk and pumpkin pie spice. Both delicious and healthy! With less than 10 ingredients, it can’t be easier to make.
Vegan Pumpkin Pie
This vegan pumpkin pie is creamier than any you’ve had before! With special ingredients like cashews and coconut sugar, you’ll be blown away by its unique flavor.
Paleo Pumpkin Pie Options
The paleo diet is an extremely popular diet at the moment. Those who eat paleo only eat vegetables, fruits, and nuts. This means that traditional Thanksgiving pumpkin pie options are out!
However, the recipes below are paleo-friendly versions of pumpkin pie. They taste unbelievably good and can be eaten by everyone!
Classic Paleo Pumpkin Pie
Who knew that paleo could be so good? This pie is sweetened with maple syrup and coconut sugar for a healthy twist!
Yummy Paleo Pumpkin Pie
This pumpkin pie is paleo, organic, and only takes one hour to cook! It’s a quick and delicious Thanksgiving pumpkin pie.
Thanksgiving is a time that we should be appreciative and celebrate both love and diversity. One way to do this is to make Thanksgiving pumpkin pie that everyone can enjoy.
Whether someone in your family has celiac disease or is lactose intolerant, there is a recipe above for them. One bite of Thanksgiving pumpkin pie and all you can think about is fall weather and bright red crunchy leaves.
While each of the recipes listed above are different, they all give you the same feeling 😉
PIN THESE RECIPES FOR LATER!